Skip to main content
Education

Head Start Advocates Want Change, Just Not the Kind the Administration Proposed

The 74

Emily Tate Sullivan ·

Head Start Advocates Want Change, Just Not the Kind the Administration Proposed
Photo: The 74

It’s been a little over three months since the Trump administration unveiled its proposal to drastically reduce the performance standards for Head Start, the federal antipoverty program that began in the 1960s and has been supported by decades of science and research. On Aug. 7, the Administration for Children and Families at the U.S. Department

It’s been a little over three months since the Trump administration unveiled its proposal to drastically reduce the performance standards for Head Start, the federal antipoverty program that began in the 1960s and has been supported by decades of science and research .

On Aug. 7, the Administration for Children and Families at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services proposed eliminating many of the services and standards — such as low adult-to-child ratios and medical, dental and developmental screenings for children — that have long established Head Start as an exemplar of early care and education in America. Following that announcement, the public was given 60 days to respond. By early October, nearly 40,000 individuals and organizations had submitted comments, many speaking out against the proposed changes.

Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter

This rule change, which many fear would erode the quality of Head Start, is the Trump administration’s latest assault on the program, critics say. The administration has already shuttered regional Head Start offices, delayed and imperiled the program’s funding and attempted to bar children based on their immigration status . Earlier this week, the administration issued a rule change canceling pay increases and improved benefits for Head Start workers.

As Head Start staff, families and advocates await a final decision that will shape the program’s next chapter, many find themselves in the position of defending the merits of Head Start, trying to justify its preservation and protection.

The fact is, most people who have enrolled in, taught for, studied or otherwise encountered Head Start would vouch for its efficacy and impact. They would also probably concede that the program can and should evolve.

“Look, there’s room for improvement, but this isn’t it,” Tommy Sheridan, deputy director of the National Head Start Association, said of the proposal. That’s a sentiment many advocates have shared in interviews with The 74.

Elliot Regenstein, a partner at Foresight Law + Policy with expertise in early learning policy and advocacy, argued that Head Start proponents should lean into that impulse.

Related Head Start’s Antipoverty Mission Threatened by Trump Administration Overhaul

“This proposal has put the early childhood advocacy community on the back heel in many ways,” Regenstein said. “The administration is pushing a vision for how Head Start could be different. It has put Head Start defenders on defense. Head Start advocates will be most successful if they can go on offense. They can do that by proposing what Head Start could look like in the next five to 10 years.”

The 74 asked six Head Start leaders, parents and policy experts how the program should improve. Here’s what they said.

Reduce bureaucracy to increase efficiency

As with any large federal program, Head Start is bogged down with processes and procedures that can, at times, be redundant and distract from the real work that program leaders are tasked with carrying out, many people noted in interviews.

Head Start funding goes directly from the federal government to local programs, rather than flowing through states. This made sense 60 years ago, when Head Start was established , because many states at that time would not have spent the money on low-income children of color, said Regenstein, who wrote about this in a paper published earlier this month about the future of Head Start.

“It was a good decision that has been core to Head Start’s success,” he said of the program’s federal-to-local management, “but the world is different now.”

To pivot suddenly from the current model to a system in which states manage Head Start would be “a terrible idea,” he added. “But it’s also the case that the relationship between states and Head Start could be different. It would be worthwhile for the field to have a conversation about what that might look like.”

Calvin Moore Jr., CEO of the Council for Professional Recognition, which administers the nationally recognized Child Development Associate credential for early childhood educators, spent 25 years working in Head Start programs, including as a director in both small and large, urban and rural settings. He also participated in Head Start as a child.

One area he sees as ripe for improvement is in the way programs are monitored. Currently, the government sends federal officials into local Head Start programs to monitor their compliance with the Head Start Program Performance Standards, on a nearly annual basis, Moore said. These federal officials often lack any local context, and program leaders end up spending time answering basic questions and providing explanations about the community. An official from New Hampshire or Florida could be sent to check on a program in Iowa, Moore said.

“Let state and local (groups) do local monitoring because they understand community conditions on the ground,” he said. “They’re often providing more timely and more practical support and better administration than federal partners at the top.”

Moore suggested that the federal government could contract with state or local agencies to do the visits, saving the government money and time and avoiding some frustration among program leaders. Or they could review recent inspection reports from the fire marshal, the state licensing body, the quality rating and improvement agency and others who routinely visit licensed programs.

“There’s a way this makes sense that is different than how it is currently being handled,” he said.

Sheridan agreed that monitoring is one of the areas that could be made more efficient. He also mentioned two other examples of ways Head Start operations could be “simplified and streamlined”: the process by which programs request to buy, renovate or build facilities and decisions about which ages a program serves.

“These are systems that already haven’t been working and … really should be the first place we need to start,” Sheridan said.

Programs are typically allotted a set number of enrollment slots for Early Head Start, which serves children under age 3, and Head Start, which serves children ages 3 to 5. This has become needlessly challenging for program operators, he said. As states roll out high-quality universal pre-K initiatives, there is a diminished need for Head Start programs to offer slots to older children, Sheridan explained, offering one example. But program leaders can’t simply transfer those slots to Early Head Start. They must apply to make that change and may not hear back about a decision for months.

“In those cases, those programs should be empowered to serve more infants and toddlers. Local communities should be making those decisions,” he said. “That’s the type of stuff that really takes away a lot of the time and energy of local Head Start programs.”

Rayna Tabanera-Geras, assistant director of early childhood education for the Port Gamble S’Klallam Tribe in Washington state, said she’s heard this complaint from other Head Start program leaders. They want flexibility and authority to serve children from birth to age 5 based on community need, just as migrant or seasonal Head Start programs currently allow.

Like the administration’s own proposal for Head Start, many of these suggestions emphasize increased flexibility and efficiency for Head Start programs. But a key difference is the administration made the unilateral decision to go through the program “with a hatchet,” said Water Gilliam, executive director of the Buffett Early Childhood Institute, seemingly without regard for all the developmental science behind it.

“I agree with the intent,” he said, “but not the process or outcome.”

Streamline the standards — don’t scrap them

The current Head Start performance standards, running 133 pages , direct programs on how to operate, from enrollment to child development to health services and family engagement.

The administration has proposed reducing that document to about a dozen pages, primarily by eliminating many of the standards that set the program apart from other early care and education settings.

Gilliam believes that at 133 pages, the current standards are “way too long.”

“I’m not going to say we shouldn’t be shrinking it. We should,” he said. “We should be attempting to get rid of regulations that aren’t necessarily helpful or could be redundant.”

But he said he would not suggest carving it down to even 30 pages, let alone 12. Many of his peers view the standards as part and parcel of Head Start’s success. Moore, of the Council for Professional Recognition, said the Head Start performance standards “set the bar.”

“Head Start has proven that these standards are good for kids and help kids be ready for kindergarten,” Moore said. “We should be thinking about more investment, not less investment.”

Head Start currently serves nearly 700,000 children and had a $12.3 billion budget in fiscal year 2025.

Moore wants to see more early care and education programs borrow from the Head Start standards, making that level of quality and rigor available to all children, regardless of income, he said. What the administration is proposing is the inverse: that Head Start standards be eliminated and programs defer to their state’s licensing standards.

Here, advocates tend to get particularly activated about adult-to-child ratios. Head Start’s ratios are stricter than most states’ childcare licensing standards . This is for good reason, many believe.

“Those (state licensing) ratios are primarily about child safety and essentially maintaining some amount of order in an early childhood setting. They are not about delivering a standards-based education,” said Regenstein, underscoring why advocates see state licensing as a floor, not a substitute for Head Start’s learning objectives. “The way the federal government is talking about ratios now makes it seem Head Start is a program whose primary purpose is custodial care.”

Tabanera-Geras, who has been working in Head Start for about 10 years and whose children have attended the program, is alarmed at the thought of higher ratios.

“Some states would have, like, 17 children with one teacher,” she said. (Three states allow one adult to care for up to 18 4-year-olds, and two allow one adult to care for up to 20 4-year-olds.) “That’s just not manageable. It becomes a safety hazard. You’re no longer providing care, and it’s just not quality.”

This issue of adult-to-child ratios reflects a key difference in how Head Start leaders want the program to improve and how the administration is proposing it should.

“Real improvement means shortening the rule book without lowering expectations, giving leaders the flexibility … without lowering child safeguards,” said Sheridan.

Protect the services that set Head Start apart

Other features of the program standards that came up as can’t-lose are inclusive classrooms and developmental screenings.

Chanta Walker is a single mom of four boys, the youngest of whom is 3 years old and received an autism diagnosis last November.

Staff at her son’s Head Start program in Cincinnati were the ones who first suggested to Walker that he be evaluated. When he was diagnosed, she said, “my mind went to the worst.” Her son’s teachers and staff educated Walker about autism spectrum disorder, helped her set up her son’s Individualized Education Program, laying out the supports and services he needs to receive, and shared relevant community resources with her.

“I was coming to this situation in the dark,” she said. But staff provided immense comfort and confidence that set her at ease.

Walker’s youngest son is included in his Head Start classroom alongside his peers.

“They treat him no different,” she said.

Staff recently sent Walker a video of her son participating in circle time, which felt momentous.

Хуваалцах:FacebookXLinkedIn